Christchurch City Council
Minutes
Date: Thursday 8 September 2022
Time: 9.33am
Venue: Council Chambers, Civic Offices,
53 Hereford Street, Christchurch
Present
|
Chairperson Deputy Chairperson Members |
Mayor Lianne Dalziel Deputy Mayor Andrew Turner Councillor Jimmy Chen Councillor Catherine Chu – via audio/visual link Councillor Melanie Coker Councillor Pauline Cotter Councillor Mike Davidson Councillor Celeste Donovan Councillor Anne Galloway Councillor James Gough Councillor Yani Johanson Councillor Aaron Keown – via audio/visual link Councillor Sam MacDonald Councillor Phil Mauger Councillor Jake McLellan Councillor Tim Scandrett Councillor Sara Templeton |
|
|
|
Principal Advisor Dawn Baxendale Chief Executive Tel: 941 8999 |
Samantha Kelly
Team Leader Hearings & Committee Support
941 6227
samantha.kelly@ccc.govt.nz
|
Council 08 September 2022 |
|
The Deputy Mayor assumed Chair.
Karakia Tīmatanga: Deputy Mayor Turner.
The agenda was dealt with in the following order.
1. Apologies Ngā Whakapāha
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00100 That the apologies received from the Mayor, Councillor Templeton and Councillor Davidson for lateness, Councillor Chu for partial absence and Councillor Galloway for absence be accepted. |
2. Declarations of Interest Ngā Whakapuaki Aronga
Deputy Mayor Turner declared an interest in Item 9.
3. Public Participation Te Huinga Tūmatanui
3.1 Public Forum Te Huinga Whānui
There were no public forum presentations.
4. Presentation of Petitions Ngā Pākikitanga
There was no presentation of petitions.
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00101 That the reports be received and considered at the Council meeting on Thursday, 8 September 2022. Open Items 22. Northcote Road - Signalised Pedestrian Crossing to support the new Marian College 23. Linwood Village Streetscapes Enhancements (S1) 24. Woolston Village - Request for an Alcohol Ban Public Excluded Items 21. Christchurch City Holdings Ltd - Appointment to the Board Deputy Mayor/Councillor Cotter Carried Councillors Coker, Johanson and McLellan requested for their votes against Public Excluded item 21 being received and considered at this meeting. Deputy Mayor Turner abstained from voting in relation to Public Excluded item 21 being received and considered at this meeting. |
Councillor Donovan joined the meeting at 9.45am during consideration of item 5.
Councillor Cotter left the meeting at 9.53am and returned at 9.54am during consideration of item 5.
Councillor Scandrett left the meeting at 9.54am and returned at 9.59am during consideration of item 5.
Councillor MacDonald left the meeting at 10.09am and returned at 10.12am during consideration of item 5.
The Mayor joined the meeting at 10.24am during consideration of item 5 and resumed the Chair.
Councillor Coker left the meeting at 10.28am and returned at 10.30am during consideration of item 5.
Councillor Gough left the meeting at 10.34am and returned at 10.36am during consideration of item 5.
|
|
Emma Norrish, Chairperson joined the meeting for presentation of the Waipapa Papanui-Innes Community Board Area Report August 2022 (Attachment 5A).
Tori Peden, Chairperson joined the meeting for presentation of the Te Pātaka o Rākaihautū Banks Peninsula Community Board Area Report July 2022 (Attachment 5B).
Kelly Barber, Chairperson joined the meeting for presentation of the Waitai Coastal-Burwood Community Board Area Report August 2022 (Attachment 5C).
Bridget Williams, Chairperson joined the meeting for presentation of the Waimāero Fendalton-Waimairi-Harewood Community Board August 2022 (Attachment 5D).
Alexandra Davids, Chairperson joined the meeting for presentation of the Waikura Linwood-Central-Heathcote Community Board Area Report August 2022 (Attachment 5E).
Karolin Potter, Chairperson joined the meeting for presentation of the Waihoro Spreydon-Cashmere Community Board Area Report August 2022 (Attachment 5F).
Mike Mora, Chairperson joined the meeting for presentation of the Waipuna Halswell-Hornby-Riccarton Community Board Area Report August 2022 (Attachment 5G).
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00102 That the Council: 1. Receive the Monthly Report from the Community Boards August 2022. 2. Delegate to the Waitai Coastal-Burwood Community Board the decision-making authority in respect of the Dedication of Road Reserve to Legal Road – Tahuna Street Wainoni report which is being considered at its meeting on Monday 12 September 2022. |
|
|
a Waipapa
Papanui-Innes Community Board Area Report August 2022 ⇨ b Te
Pātaka o Rākaihautū Banks Peninsula Community Board Area
Report July 2022 ⇨ c Waitai
Coastal-Burwood Community Board Area Report August 2022 ⇨ d Waimāero
Fendalton-Waimairi-Harewood Community Board August 2022 ⇨ e Waikura
Linwood-Central-Heathcote Community Board Area Report August 2022 ⇨ f Waihoro
Spreydon-Cashmere Community Board Area Report August 2022 ⇨ g Waipuna
Halswell-Hornby-Riccarton Community Board Area Report August 2022 ⇨ |
Meeting adjourned at 11.05am and reconvened at 11.23am. Councillor Donovan was not present at this time.
|
Report from Linwood-Central-Heathcote Community Board - 17 August 2022 |
|
|
24. Woolston Village - Request for an Alcohol Ban |
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00103 Community Board recommendations accepted without change That the Council: 1. Investigates establishing an alcohol ban in Woolston Village and surrounding streets under the Alcohol Restrictions in Public Places Bylaw 2018. 2. Requests staff to review and streamline the process for setting up an alcohol ban. |
|
6. Health, Safety and Wellbeing Committee Minutes - 5 August 2022 |
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00104 That the Council receives the Minutes from the Health, Safety and Wellbeing Committee meeting held 5 August 2022. Mayor/Councillor McLellan Carried |
Councillor Chu left the meeting at 11.28am and returned at 11.35am during consideration of item 8.
Councillor Donovan returned to the meeting at 11.35am during consideration of item 8.
|
|
The Council accepted the Officer recommendations with the addition of including ‘air’ to page 94 of the Strategy.
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00105 That the Council: 1. Receive the information in the attached Smart Christchurch Strategy and this report, noting that a reference to air will be added to page 94 of the Strategy. 2. Adopt the Smart Christchurch Strategy. |
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00106 That Alex Skinner of Christchurch City Holdings Limited, remain after the public have been excluded for Item 21 of the public excluded agenda as he has knowledge that is relevant to that item and will assist the Council. AND That at 11.37am the resolution to exclude the public set out on pages 214 to 215 of the agenda and pages 5 to 6 of the supplementary agenda be adopted. Mayor/Councillor Chen Carried |
Councillor Davidson and Councillor Templeton joined the meeting at 11.51am during the public excluded section of the meeting.
The public were re-admitted to the meeting at 12.20pm.
|
|
The Mayor tabled a letter dated 5 September 2022 titled Whakawhanake Kainga Komiti – Urban Growth Partnership (refer to Attachment 9A).
The Council accepted the Mayor’s Recommendations including an additional recommendation (7) to withdraw from C4LD. Recommendation 7 was declared carried by way of division.
Deputy Mayor Turner declared a conflict of interest and sat back from the table for this item.
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00107 That the Council: 1. Acknowledges our statutory obligations to facilitate participation by Māori in Council’s decision-making processes and reconfirms that Council will engage with Ngā Papatipu Rūnanga in accordance with our established partnership arrangements. 2. Confirms its commitment to an enduring collaborative relationship with Ngā Papatipu Rūnanga. 3. Notes that the Chief Executive will amend the Council’s report template to ensure Council considers all the issues that have significance to mana whenua before any decision. 4. Notes the Council is opposed to the model proposed in the Government’s Three Waters reform. 5. Agrees that the Council will continue to work collaboratively across the sector to improve the outcomes of the Three Waters Reforms in a manner consistent with our stated position, while ensuring that every opportunity is taken to respect and extend our Treaty partnership with Ngā Papatipu Rūnanga and the participation of Māori in decision-making. 6. Notes that the process followed in making the decision to join Communities 4 Local Democracy (C4LD) was inconsistent with our commitments to Ngā Papatipu Rūnanga and formally apologises. Mayor/Councillor Davidson Carried Deputy Mayor Turner sat back from the table and took no part in the discussion or voting on this item. |
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00108 7. Agrees to withdraw from C4LD and engages with Ngā Papatipu Rūnanga, recognising the impact of our failure to engage with Ngā Papatipu Rūnanga prior to our decision to join C4LD on wider relationships. Mayor/Councillor Davidson Carried The division was declared carried by 7 votes to 6 votes the voting being as follows: For: Mayor Dalziel, Councillor Coker, Councillor Davidson, Councillor Donovan, Councillor Mauger, Councillor McLellan and Councillor Templeton Against: Councillor Chu, Councillor Cotter, Councillor Gough, Councillor Keown, Councillor MacDonald and Councillor Scandrett Abstained: Councillor Chen and Councillor Johanson Deputy Mayor Turner sat back from the table and took no part in the discussion or voting on this item. |
|
|
a Letter
dated 5 September 2022 Titled: Whakawhanake Kainga Komiti – Urban
Growth Partnership ⇨ |
The meeting adjourned at 1.10pm and reconvened at 2.05pm.
3.2 Deputations by Appointment Ngā Huinga Whakaritenga
|
Tony Simons spoke on
behalf of the Riccarton Bush Kilmarnock Residents’ Association
regarding item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. |
|
a Riccarton
Bush Kilmarnock Resident's Association - Additional Documentation ⇨ |
|
Marc Duff and Ross
Houliston spoke on behalf of the Greater Hornby Residents' Association will
speak regarding item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. |
|
a Greater
Hornby Resident's Association - Additional Documentation ⇨ |
|
Geoff Banks and David
Chambers spoke on behalf of the Victoria Neighbourhood Association regarding
item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. |
|
a Victoria
Neighbourhood Association - Presentation ⇨ |
|
Grant Wilson spoke on
behalf of the Central Riccarton Residents' Association regarding item 7
Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. |
|
a Central
Riccarton Resident's Association - Additional Documentation ⇨ |
|
Mark Wilson spoke on behalf of the St Albans Residents' Association regarding item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. |
Councillor Gough left meeting at 2.40pm during deputation 3.2.8.
|
Greg Partridge spoke
regarding item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. The petition titled
“Object to the Christchurch environment and city centre being ruined by
bad planning” and contained 1658
signatures. |
|
a Greg
Partridge (Christchurch Neighbourhood Community Collective) - Additional
Documentation ⇨ b Greg
Partridge - Presentation ⇨ |
Councillor Gough returned meeting at 2.43pm during deputation 3.2.6.
|
Julie Tobbell spoke on behalf of the Somerfield Residents' Association regarding item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. |
|
Debbie Mora spoke on
behalf of the Halswell Hornby Riccarton Community Board regarding item 7
Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. |
|
a Halswell-Hornby-Riccarton
Community Board Deputation - Additional Documentation 1 ⇨ b Halswell-Hornby-Riccarton
Community Board Deputation - Additional Documentation 2 ⇨ |
|
David Lynch and Barbara
Stewart spoke on behalf of Momentus Public Relations Ltd regarding item 7
Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14. |
|
a Momentus
Public Relations - Additional Documentation ⇨ |
|
Lucy Alborn spoke regarding item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14 |
|
Peter Wakeman spoke regarding item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14 |
The meeting adjourned at 3.17pm and reconvened at 3.21pm.
|
Helen Broughton spoke regarding item 7 Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14 (via audio/visual link). |
Councillors Gough and MacDonald left meeting at 4:24pm and returned to the meeting at 4:26pm during item 7.
The meeting adjourned at 4.54pm and reconvened at 5.03pm during consideration of item 7.
7. Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14
Council Officers provided a PowerPoint presentation (Refer to Attachment 7A which can be found below the final resolutions for this item) and Councillors were provided an opportunity to ask questions of clarification.
Councillors were also provided an opportunity to indicate proposed amendments they were considering putting forward.
The meeting adjourned and reconvened on Tuesday 13 September 2022 to
consider the item.
The meeting adjourned at 5.04pm to 8am, Tuesday 13 September 2022, Civic Offices, 53 Hereford Street.
The meeting reconvened at 8am, Tuesday 13 September 2022. Councillors Johanson and MacDonald were not present at this time. Councillor Chu joined the meeting via audio/visual link.
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00109 It was resolved on the motion of The Mayor, seconded by Councillor Templeton, that the apologies for lateness from Deputy Mayor Turner and Councillor Donovan be accepted and the apology from Councillor Chen for absence be accepted. Mayor/Councillor Templeton Carried |
Deputy Mayor Turner and Councillor MacDonald joined the meeting at 8.06am during consideration of item 7.
Councillors Donovan and Johanson joined the meeting at 8.08am during consideration of item 7.
Councillor Gough left the meeting at 8.20am and returned at 8.25am during consideration of item 7.
7. Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14
At the meeting on Tuesday 13 September 2022 Council Officers provided a further PowerPoint presentation (refer to Attachment 7B which can be found below the final resolutions for this item).
Additional documents provided by the Christchurch Civic Trust were tabled at the meeting, (refer to Attachment 7C which can be found below the final resolutions for this item).
Following the Officers’ presentation, Councillors identified the proposed amendments they wished to proceed with (Refer to Attachment 7D which can be found below the final resolutions for this item) and indicated their Seconders. Councillors were also provided with an opportunity to ask questions of clarification.
The item was then adjourned to later in the meeting.
|
Report from Papanui-Innes Community Board - 2 September 2022 |
|
|
22. Northcote Road - Signalised Pedestrian Crossing to support the new Marian College |
|
|
|
The Council accepted the Community Board recommendations with a minor change to recommendation 5.
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00110 That the Council: 1. Approve the installation of traffic signals (to facilitate pedestrians and cyclists crossing Northcote Road), including all associated road markings on Northcote Road to the east of its intersection with Lydia Street as detailed in Attachment A of the report. 2. Revoke the existing permanent speed limit of 40 kilometres per hour on Lydia Street (entire length). 3. Approve pursuant to Part 4 Clause 27 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017 and Land Transport Rule, Setting of Speed Limits 2022: that the permanent speed limit on Lydia Street be set at 30 kilometres per hour (entire length). 4. Requests that staff work with Foodstuffs to investigate an opportunity to create a shared path to link Main North Road and Lydia Street via Foodstuffs land. 5. Requests for the funding of the scheme design for the Northcote Road Corridor Improvement Project (Line 915 in the LTP) to be bought forward as part of the draft 2023-24 Annual Plan in order to provide a link between the Northern Line cycleway and the QEII shared path. |
Councillor Gough left the meeting at 8.58am and returned at 9.01am during consideration of item 23.
|
Report from Linwood-Central-Heathcote Community Board - 31 August 2022 |
|
|
23. Linwood Village Streetscapes Enhancements (S1) |
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00111 Community Board recommendations accepted without change That the Council: 1. Revokes any previously approved resolutions on Stanmore Road from its intersection with Hereford Street, and extending in a northerly direction to its intersection with Gloucester Street, pertaining to traffic controls, made pursuant to any bylaw, to the extent that they are in conflict with the traffic controls described in recommendations 2-12 below. 2. Approves that the speed limit be set at 30 kilometres per hour, in accordance with Clause 27 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017 on Stanmore Road, commencing at its intersection with Hereford Street and extending in a northerly direction to its intersection with Worcester Street. 3. Approves that the speed limit be set at 30 kilometres per hour within the intersection of Stanmore Road and Worcester Street, in accordance with Clause 27 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017. 4. Approves that the speed limit be set at 30 kilometres per hour, in accordance with Clause 27 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017 on Stanmore Road, commencing at its intersection with Worcester Street and extending in a northerly direction to its intersection with Gloucester Street. 5. Approves that a Special Vehicle Lane, in accordance with Clause 18 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017, for the use of northbound cycles only be installed on the west side of Stanmore Road, commencing at its intersection with Hereford Street, and extending in a northerly direction to its intersection with Worcester Street, as detailed on plan TP359201, sheet 1, dated 12/08/2022 and attached to the agenda report as Attachment B. 6. Approves that a Special Vehicle Lane, in accordance with Clause 18 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017, for the use of southbound cycles only be installed on the east side of Stanmore Road, commencing at its intersection with Worcester Street, and extending in a southerly direction for a distance of 63 metres, as detailed on plan TP359201, sheet 1, dated 12/08/2022 and attached to the agenda report as Attachment B. 7. Approves that a Special Vehicle Lane, in accordance with Clause 18 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017, for the use of northbound cycles only be installed on the west side of Stanmore Road, commencing at its intersection with Worcester Street, and extending in a northerly direction for a distance of 50 metres, as detailed on plan TP359201, sheet 1, dated 26/04/2022 and attached to the agenda report as Attachment B. 8. Approves that a Special Vehicle Lane, in accordance with Clause 18 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017, for the use of northbound cycles only be installed on the west side of Stanmore Road, commencing at a point 92 metres north of its intersection with Worcester Street, and extending in a northerly direction to its intersection with Gloucester Street, as detailed on plan TP359201, sheet 1, dated 26/04/2022 and attached to this report as Attachment B. 9. Approves that a Special Vehicle Lane, in accordance with Clause 18 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic & Parking Bylaw 2017, for the use of southbound cycles only be installed on the east side of Stanmore Road, commencing at its intersection with Gloucester Street, and extending in a southerly direction to its intersection with Worcester Street, as detailed on plan TP359201, sheet 1, dated 26/04/2022 and attached to the agenda report as Attachment B. 10. Approves that a Special Vehicle Lane, in accordance with Clause 18 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017, for the use of westbound cycles only be installed on the south side of Gloucester Street, commencing at its intersection with Stanmore Road, and extending in a westerly direction for a distance of 21 metres, as detailed on plan TP359201, sheet 1, dated 12/08/2022 and attached to the agenda report as Attachment B. 11. Approves that a Special Vehicle Lane, in accordance with Clause 18 of the Christchurch City Council Traffic and Parking Bylaw 2017, for the use of eastbound cycles only be installed on the north side of Gloucester Street, commencing at its intersection with Stanmore Road, and extending in a westerly direction for a distance of 21 metres, as detailed on plan TP359201, sheet 1, dated 12/08/2022 and attached to the agenda report as Attachment B. 12. Approves that all traffic movements at the Stanmore Road and Gloucester Street intersection be controlled by Traffic Signals, in accordance with Sections 6 and 10.5 of the Land Transport Rule: Traffic Control Devices 2004. Linwood Village Enhancement and Safety Improvements – Project to proceed 98. Approves that the project shall proceed to detailed design, as detailed on Attachment B of the agenda report together with the following additional items to be included in the detailed design: a. Cycle stands as close as possible to the shopping precincts within Linwood Village. b. A plaque to be installed adjacent to 389/389A Worcester Street in remembrance of the lives lost in 22 February 2011 earthquake in Linwood Village. c. The proposed creative lighting feature. 99. Approves that the project shall proceed to construction subject to adequate budget being available to meet the contract commitments for construction. Councillor McLellan/Councillor Templeton Carried
|
|
10. Canterbury Museum Temporary Access Easement Through the Botanic Gardens |
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00112 Officer recommendations accepted without change That the Council: 1. Approve pursuant to Section 48(1)(a) and (f) of the Reserves Act 1977, the granting of a temporary unregistered right of way easement to Canterbury Museum over that part of the Local Purpose (Botanic Garden) Reserve known as Botanic Gardens (Part Reserve 25 contained in Record of Title 668229) shown as the shaded area on the plan below at paragraph 5.3, subject to: a. Consent from the Minister of Conservation for the easement (delegated to the Council and sub-delegated to the Council’s Chief Executive) being obtained. b. All necessary statutory consents under, but not limited to, the Resource Management Act and Building Act being obtained by Canterbury Museum. c. Canterbury Museum meeting its own costs associated with the creation and execution of this easement. d. Canterbury Museum liaising with the Council’s Parks Unit regarding access, programming, health & safety, and any remediation activities associated with the temporary right of way and access over the Botanic Gardens. 2. Authorises the Property Consultancy Manager, should the temporary easement be granted, to conclude negotiations to finalise the terms of a temporary easement agreement with Canterbury Museum including the signing of any associated documentation to implement the temporary easement proposed by this report and to protect the Council’s interests. Councillor MacDonald/Councillor Keown Carried
|
|
11. Community Applications to the 2022/2023 Capital Endowment Fund |
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00113 Officer recommendations accepted without change That the Council: 1. Approves a grant of $75,000 from the 2022/2023 Capital Endowment Fund, released as one instalment to the Canterbury Society of Artists Trust for the renewal of HVAC in the CoCA Gallery building at 66 Gloucester Street. Conditional upon: a. The Canterbury Society of Artists Trust demonstrating that they have sufficient resources to complete the project and maintain the HVAC system. b. The Canterbury Society of Artists Trust agreeing to return the Grant in full if the building is disposed of (sold, leased for a purpose other than public access to community arts and culture or cease to be open to the community) within ten (10) years of the Grant being paid. c. The Council obtaining appropriate security against the (CoCA Gallery) building asset to ensure the repayment of the Grant if necessary. 2. Requires final reporting is to be submitted by the Canterbury Society of Artists Trust 6 months following the drawdown of the Grant. 3. Approves a grant of $50,000 from the 2022/2023 Capital Endowment Fund, to be released as one instalment to the Santa Parade for the refurbishment of floats and other essential Santa Parade event infrastructure. Conditional upon: a. The Santa Parade demonstrating that they have sufficient resources to complete the project and run the 2022 Santa Parade Event as planned at Canterbury Agricultural Park. 4. Requires final reporting to be submitted 6 months following drawdown of the Grant and includes commentary on the overall sustainability of the Santa Parade Event in general. 5. Notes that there can be no expectation of further Council funding of the Santa Parade Event and Santa Parade Organisation other than through its contestable community funding schemes, namely the Strengthening Communities and Events and Festivals Fund. 6. Delegates to the Head of Community Support and Partnerships the authority to make the necessary arrangements to fulfil resolutions 1 to 5 noting that Council’s Legal Services Unit will prepare the necessary documentation. 7. Resolves that publically excluded Attachments C and D will be released to the public with the exception of the Canterbury Society of Artists Trust financial information by 31 December 2022 or when lease arrangements for the CoCA Gallery are concluded. Councillor Johanson/Councillor Scandrett Carried
|
Councillor MacDonald left the meeting at 9.08am and returned at 9.09am during consideration of item 12.
Councillor Coker left the meeting at 9.09am and returned at 9.10am during consideration of item 12.
|
12. Hearings Panel report to the Council on the Duvauchelle Treated Wastewater Options |
|
|
|
The Council accepted the Hearings Panel recommendations with additional changes to recommendations 7 and 8.
|
|
|
Hearings Panel Recommendations That the Council: 1. Receives and consider the information in the report, the submissions, and all other relevant information received on the Duvauchelle treated wastewater options. 2. Approves the adoption of Option 1: spray and drip irrigate treated wastewater to the Akaroa Golf Course. 3. Requests Officers incorporate provision for future non-potable reuse. 4. Supports a long term lease for Akaroa Golf Club. 5. Makes provision in the Long Term Plan for increased operational costs for the Akaroa Golf Club associated with the needs of the scheme. 6. Requests that Officers work closely with the Ōnuku Rūnanga, Akaroa Golf Club, Duvauchelle Primary School and Banks Peninsula Early Learning Incorporated and Trust during the design development and resource consent process. 7. Requests as a minimum that the resource consent application is limited notified. 8. Notes other concerns raised by submitters about potential environmental effects will be addressed through the resource consent process. |
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00114 That the Council: 1. Receives and consider the information in the report, the submissions, and all other relevant information received on the Duvauchelle treated wastewater options. 2. Approves the adoption of Option 1: spray and drip irrigate treated wastewater to the Akaroa Golf Course. 3. Requests Officers incorporate provision for future non-potable reuse. 4. Supports a long term lease for Akaroa Golf Club. 5. Makes provision in the Long Term Plan for increased operational costs for the Akaroa Golf Club associated with the needs of the scheme. 6. Requests that Officers work closely with the Ōnuku Rūnanga, Akaroa Golf Club, Duvauchelle Primary School and Banks Peninsula Early Learning Incorporated and Trust during the design development and resource consent process. 7. Requests as a minimum that the resource consent application is limited notified to affected parties. 8. Recognises the concerns raised by submitters about potential environmental effects and requests staff to ensure these are addressed through the resource consent application process. Councillor Davidson/Councillor Cotter Carried
|
13. Flood Management Options for Edgeware Road at Edgeware Village
Council Officers provided a PowerPoint presentation (refer to Attachment 13A which can be found below the resolutions for this item).
The item was then adjourned to later in the meeting.
|
16. Regulatory Services - Building Consenting Unit Report - June and July 2022 |
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00115 Officer recommendation accepted without change That the Council: 1. Receive the information in the Regulatory Services Building Consenting Update Report – June and July 2022. Councillor Scandrett/Councillor Cotter Carried
|
|
13. Flood Management Options for Edgeware Road at Edgeware Village |
|
|
|
Council Officers provided a PowerPoint presentation (Attachment 13A).
The Council accepted the Officer recommendations including an additional recommendation (5).
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00116 That the Council: 1. Continue with and extend the engagement with the local community, including business owners, over flooding matters including providing advice to assist property owners in taking their own measures to reduce the impacts of flooding on their properties; and 2. Rely on the District Plan floor level controls to provide the most certain means to reduce flood risk to buildings in Edgeware village over time; and 3. Update the costs of the engineered option in advance of the next Long Term Plan (LTP), giving consideration to other options, levels of service, Council policy and the occurrence of similar flooding in other parts of the city as part of consideration of potential LTP candidates; and 4. Consider construction of a full height kerb as part of the ongoing Edgeware Village Master Plan work. 5. Request staff to prepare a report on surface flooding across urban Christchurch and recommend potential stormwater projects for consideration in the annual plan. Councillor Cotter/Councillor Mauger Carried
|
|
|
a Flood
Management Options for Edgeware Village - Staff Presentation ⇨ |
7. Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14
The Mayor tabled updated recommendations and two associated maps (refer to Attachment 7E which can be found below the resolutions for this item).
The item was then adjourned to later in the meeting.
The meeting adjourned at 10.45am and reconvened at 11.39am. Councillor Donovan was not present at this time.
7. Approval to notify Plan Changes 13 and 14
The Mayor moved a set of updated recommendations which was Seconded by Councillor Templeton (refer to Attachment 7E which can be found below the resolutions for this item).
In addition, with the approval of the Mover and Seconder, the Councillor’s proposed amendments which were supported by Council Officers were included as part of the Motion. (Refer to the resolutions attached to this item).
The item was then adjourned to later in the meeting.
The Mayor left the meeting at 11.49am and Deputy Mayor Turner assumed the Chair.
Deputy Mayor Turner advised that Public Excluded items 18 and 19 were deferred to 15 September 2022 Council meeting.
|
|
The Council accepted the Officer recommendations and included an additional recommendation (4).
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00117 That the Council: 1. Receive the information in the Central City Shuttle Update report. 2. Add a Central City Shuttle trial design project to the public transport work programme in the period 2023-24, subject to funding in the 2023/24 Annual Plan, to inform the 2024-34 Long Term Plan for consideration of a permanent shuttle service. 3. Acknowledge that this work will occur without disrupting existing priorities. 4. Notes the preference for a zero emission shuttle. Councillor Templeton/Councillor McLellan Carried
|
The Mayor returned to the meeting and assumed the Chair.
|
|
Meeting Process:
At the meeting on Thursday 8 September 2022 Council Officers provided a PowerPoint presentation (refer to Attachment 7A) and Councillors were provided an opportunity to ask questions of clarification. The meeting then adjourned and reconvened on Tuesday 13 September 2022 to consider the item.
At the meeting on Tuesday 13 September 2022 Council Officers provided a further PowerPoint presentation (refer to Attachment 7B).
Additional documents provided by the Christchurch Civic Trust were also tabled at the meeting, (refer to Attachment 7C).
Following the Officers presentation Councillors identified the proposed amendments they wished to proceed (refer to Attachment 7D), advised the meeting of their Seconders. Councillors also had an opportunity to ask questions of clarification of Council Officers. The item was then adjourned to later in the meeting.
The Mayor tabled a set of updated recommendations and two associated maps (refer to Attachment 7E). The item was then adjourned to later in the meeting.
The Mayor tabled further updates to the recommendations tabled earlier in the meeting (refer to Attachment 7E). The recommendations were Moved by the Mayor and Seconded by Councillor Templeton. In addition, with the approval of the Mover and Seconder, the Councillor proposed amendments which were supported by Council Officers were included as part of the Motion. The item was then adjourned to later in the meeting.
The item was then opened for debate. Following debate, the recommendations were put to the vote in the following order (refer to the individual resolutions for the final decision and voting record): - Councillor amendments - Resolutions 8a, 9a, 10,12,16,17,18 and 15 - Resolution 1 - Resolution 2.1 and 2.2 - Resolutions 5 and 6 - Resolution 2
Secretarial Note: The numbering of some of the resolutions are associated with the numbering referred to in Attachment 7E.
|
|
|
Officer Recommendations That the Council: 1. Approve the public notification of Plan Change 13 Heritage and its associated evaluation report (prepared in accordance with section 32 of the RMA) as included in attachments to this report, pursuant to Clause 5 of Schedule 1 of the RMA. 2. Approve the public notification of Plan Change 14 Housing and Business Choice and its associated evaluation report (prepared in accordance with sections 32 and 77J-77R of the RMA) as included in attachments to this report, pursuant to Clause 5 of Schedule 1 of the RMA. 3. Authorise Head of Planning and Consents to make any necessary minor corrections or amendments to the Proposed Plan Changes 13 and 14 or their evaluation reports and appendices, until the date of notification, to improve the clarity, accuracy or consistency of the documents. 4. Authorise Head of Planning and Consents to make other consequential changes to chapters of the District Plan not otherwise affected by Plan Changes 14 and 13 and to approve those documents for notification.
|
|
|
The Motion was Moved by the Mayor and Seconded by Councillor Templeton That the Council: 1. Approve the
public notification of Plan Change 13 Heritage and its associated evaluation
report (prepared in accordance with section 32 of the RMA) as included in
attachments to this report, pursuant to Clause 5 of Schedule 1 of the RMA. 2. Approve the public notification of Plan Change 14 Housing and Business Choice and its associated evaluation report (prepared in accordance with sections 32 and 77J-77R of the RMA) as included in attachments to this report, and amendments made at this meeting, pursuant to Clause 5 of Schedule 1 of the RMA.
2.1
Staff investigate making a submission to limit
the extent of the area enabled for medium density development, to less than
the staff recommendation, by: a. Identification of a qualifying matter to reflect the lesser accessibility to centres and public transport; b. Implementing the qualifying matter by zoning areas as Low Density (qualifying matter – public transport accessibility) Zone as shown on the attached map “Spatial overview of Alternative resolution to Plan Change 14 proposal” dated 12th September 2022; and c. Restricting development in that zone to a level the same as the Residential Suburban zone in the Operative District Plan.
2.2
Subject to 2.1, the areas zoned Medium Density
Residential (MRZ) as recommended by staff would be reduced to the following
areas as shown on the attached map titled “Spatial overview of
Alternative resolution to Plan Change 14 proposal” dated 12th
September 2022: a. Within a walkable distance of
i.
approximately 1km radius of the 5 main core
bus routes identified in the PT Futures Business case; and ii. approximately 200m from the Bishopdale commercial centre, and within areas most accessible by walking to the Merivale/Bryndwr (No 17) bus route, the Fendalton to Airport (No 29) bus route and the City to Shirley bus route (No 7 and 44); except where
other proposed qualifying matters apply and with the boundaries of the zone
defined to ensure coherent and logical zone boundary (block) extents are
achieved; b.
Within all existing areas zoned as Residential
Suburban Density Transition and Residential Medium Zones under the operative
Christchurch District Plan; 3 Authorise Head of Planning and Consents to make any necessary minor corrections or amendments to the Proposed Plan Changes 13 and 14 or their evaluation reports and appendices, until the date of notification, to improve the clarity, accuracy or consistency of the documents.
4 Authorise Head of Planning and Consents to make other consequential changes to chapters of the District Plan not otherwise affected by Plan Changes 14 and 13 and to approve those documents for notification.
5 Request staff to amend the PC14 identification of properties that are subject to the Riccarton Bush Interface qualifying matter to include all of those properties identified in blue on the following plan and 11C Kauri Street.
6 Request Environment Canterbury to undertake an urgent review of public transport coverage in light of the requirement to notify Plan Change 14. 8a. Request staff to lead evidence in the Plan Change 14 process that reassesses the biome identification in the Section32 report, and addresses any implications for proposed provisions that arise from that reassessment. 9a. Request staff to investigate whether they support adding the cottages at 62, 64, 74 and 76 Chancellor Street to the schedule of heritage items in Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 and, if supported by staff, lodge a submission seeking that addition. 10. Request staff to investigate whether they support adding all of Woodville St as a residential character area or residential heritage area in Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 and, if supported by staff, lodge a submission seeking that addition. 12. Request staff to investigate whether they support adding Mersey Street from Westminster Street to Berwick Street as a residential character area or residential heritage area in Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 and, if supported by staff, lodge a submission seeking that addition. 15. Request staff to investigate adding the Upper Riccarton War Library to the schedule of heritage items in Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 and, if supported by staff, lodge a submission seeking that addition. 16. Request staff to investigate the impact of flood risk on accesses to properties as a possible qualifying matter that warrants limits on intensification and, if staff consider it warranted, lodge a submission seeking a qualifying matter constraint on intensification on that basis. 17. Request staff to engage experts to investigate the effects from industrial zones on intensified residential activity in proximate residential areas, and make a staff submission seeking changes to the proposal to address those effects and/or produce evidence in the Independent Hearings Panel process consistent with the outcome of that investigation.
18. That the Council request staff to: a. commission a social impact assessment of the effect of the intensification enabled by Plan Change 14; and b. lodge a Council submission to make that social impact assessment relevant, by asking in the Council submission that changes be made to the proposal to appropriately address findings of a social impact assessment; and c. produce evidence of the social impact assessment, and planning analysis of it, in the Independent Hearings Panel process; and d. report the social impact assessment findings to Council so that Council may consider other Council actions in response; and e. investigate and report on, as part of developing the Otautahi Christchurch Plan, Council actions to mitigate the environmental impacts of implementing the NPS-UD, in time to inform the draft Long Term plan. Mayor/Councillor Templeton Carried/Lost
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00118 Amendment 7. Councillor Coker That the Council: Request staff to make any changes necessary to the Plan Change 14 provisions to require 25% tree canopy cover on residential sites rather than 20%. Councillor Coker/Councillor Cotter Carried Councillors Keown and Mauger requested for their votes against the resolution be recorded
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00119 Amendment 11. Councillor McLellan That the Council: Request staff to make any changes to Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 to extend the Chester St East/Dawson St heritage area (HA2) to include all properties with a Chester St East address east of the currently proposed HA2 boundary. Councillor McLellan/Councillor Cotter Carried Councillors Donovan, Templeton, MacDonald and Davidson requested for their votes against the resolution be recorded.
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00120 Amendment 13. Councillor McLellan That the Council: Request staff to amend Plan Change 14 provisions that enabled building heights around the Victoria Street area (where a 45m City Centre Zone limit is proposed) are reduced from 32m to 20m. Councillor McLellan/Councillor Cotter Carried Councillors Keown and Templeton requested for their votes against the resolution be recorded
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00121 Amendment 14. Councillor Johanson That the Council: Request staff to add to Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 a new residential heritage area consisting of all properties of a consistent age with a Woodham Road address. Councillor Johanson/Councillor Coker Carried Councillor Templeton requested for her vote against the resolution be recorded
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00122 Amendment 19. Councillor Chu That the Council: Request staff to amend the PC14 identification of properties that are subject to the Riccarton Bush Interface qualifying matter to include all of those recommended by staff and also 1/17, 19A, 21, 23, 27, 29 and 31 Kahu Road. Councillor Chu/Councillor MacDonald Carried
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00123 That the Council: 8a. Request staff to lead evidence in the Plan Change 14 process that reassesses the biome identification in the Section32 report, and addresses any implications for proposed provisions that arise from that reassessment. 9a. Request staff to investigate whether they support adding the cottages at 62, 64, 74 and 76 Chancellor Street to the schedule of heritage items in Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 and, if supported by staff, lodge a submission seeking that addition. 10. Request staff to investigate whether they support adding all of Woodville St as a residential character area or residential heritage area in Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 and, if supported by staff, lodge a submission seeking that addition. 12. Request staff to investigate whether they support adding Mersey Street from Westminster Street to Berwick Street as a residential character area or residential heritage area in Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 and, if supported by staff, lodge a submission seeking that addition. 15. Request staff to investigate adding the Upper Riccarton War Library to the schedule of heritage items in Plan Change 13 and Plan Change 14 and, if supported by staff, lodge a submission seeking that addition. 16. Request staff to investigate the impact of flood risk on accesses to properties as a possible qualifying matter that warrants limits on intensification and, if staff consider it warranted, lodge a submission seeking a qualifying matter constraint on intensification on that basis. 17. Request staff to engage experts to investigate the effects from industrial zones on intensified residential activity in proximate residential areas, and make a staff submission seeking changes to the proposal to address those effects and/or produce evidence in the Independent Hearings Panel process consistent with the outcome of that investigation.
18. That the Council request staff to: a. commission a social impact assessment of the effect of the intensification enabled by Plan Change 14; and b. lodge a Council submission to make that social impact assessment relevant, by asking in the Council submission that changes be made to the proposal to appropriately address findings of a social impact assessment; and c. produce evidence of the social impact assessment, and planning analysis of it, in the Independent Hearings Panel process; and d. report the social impact assessment findings to Council so that Council may consider other Council actions in response; and e. investigate and report on, as part of developing the Otautahi Christchurch Plan, Council actions to mitigate the environmental impacts of implementing the NPS-UD, in time to inform the draft Long Term plan. Mayor/Councillor Templeton Carried
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00124 That the Council: 1. Approve the public notification of Plan Change 13 Heritage and its associated evaluation report (prepared in accordance with section 32 of the RMA) as included in attachments to this report, pursuant to Clause 5 of Schedule 1 of the RMA. Mayor/Councillor Templeton Carried
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00125 That the Council request : 2.1 Staff investigate making a submission to limit the
extent of the area enabled for medium density development, to less than the
staff recommendation, by: a. Identification of a qualifying matter to reflect the lesser accessibility to centres and public transport; b. Implementing the qualifying matter by zoning areas as Low Density (qualifying matter – public transport accessibility) Zone as shown on the attached map “Spatial overview of Alternative resolution to Plan Change 14 proposal” dated 12th September 2022; and c. Restricting development in that zone to a level the same as the Residential Suburban zone in the Operative District Plan.
2.2 Subject to 2.1, the areas zoned Medium
Density Residential (MRZ) as recommended by staff would be reduced to the
following areas as shown on the attached map titled “Spatial overview
of Alternative resolution to Plan Change 14 proposal” dated 12th
September 2022: a. Within a walkable distance of
i.
approximately 1km radius of the 5 main core
bus routes identified in the PT Futures Business case; and ii. approximately 200m from the Bishopdale commercial centre, and within areas most accessible by walking to the Merivale/Bryndwr (No 17) bus route, the Fendalton to Airport (No 29) bus route and the City to Shirley bus route (No 7 and 44); except where
other proposed qualifying matters apply and with the boundaries of the zone
defined to ensure coherent and logical zone boundary (block) extents are
achieved; b. Within all existing areas zoned as Residential Suburban Density Transition and Residential Medium Zones under the operative Christchurch District Plan; Mayor/Councillor Templeton Carried
|
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00126 That the
Council: 5. Request staff to amend the PC14 identification of properties that are subject to the Riccarton Bush Interface qualifying matter to include all of those properties identified in blue on the following plan and 11C Kauri Street. 6. Request Environment Canterbury to undertake an urgent review of public transport coverage in light of the requirement to notify Plan Change 14. Mayor/Councillor Templeton Carried Councillor Donovan requested for her vote against the resolutions be recorded. |
|
|
That the Council: 2. Approve the public notification of Plan Change 14 Housing and Business Choice and its associated evaluation report (prepared in accordance with sections 32 and 77J-77R of the RMA) as included in attachments to this report, and amendments made at this meeting, pursuant to Clause 5 of Schedule 1 of the RMA. Mayor/Councillor Templeton Lost The division was declared lost by 5 votes to 10 votes the voting being as follows: For: Mayor Dalziel, Deputy Mayor Turner, Councillor Davidson, Councillor Donovan and Councillor Templeton Against: Councillor Chu, Councillor Coker, Councillor Cotter, Councillor Galloway, Councillor Gough, Councillor Johanson, Councillor Keown, Councillor MacDonald, Councillor Mauger and Councillor McLellan Abstained: Councillor Scandrett |
|
|
Council Resolved CNCL/2022/00127 Amendment 20. Councillor Johanson That the Council: a. Write to the Minister expressing its concerns with this legislation and process. b. Request the Minister work with us in partnership given our unique situation that means we have sufficient capacity of land in the short, medium, and long term available for housing given our extensive land use planning changes to increase density and intensification post-earthquake, and look at land use planning that addresses the issues of housing affordability and sustainable development. Councillor Johanson/Councillor Keown Carried
|
|
|
a Approval
to Notify Plan Changes - Staff Presentation (8th September) ⇨ b Approval
to Notify Plan Changes - Staff Presentation (13th September) ⇨ c Christchurch
Civic Trust - Documentation ⇨ d Proposed Councillor Amendments ⇨ e Mayor's Recommendations and Maps ⇨ |
|
|
Item 15 was deferred to the 15 September 2022 Council meeting.
|
Karakia Whakamutunga: The Mayor
Meeting concluded at 1.09pm.
CONFIRMED BY THE CHAIRPERSON AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE ON 4TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2022 PURSUANT TO STANDING ORDER 23.4
Mayor Lianne Dalziel
Chairperson
DAWN BAXENDALE
CHIEF EXECUTIVE